A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana has taken over and turned what was once a falling apart building into a classy pizza parlor.

Fresh salads, appetizers, and pizza are on the menu at this Jasper County pizza parlor!

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

I asked the owner of A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana “What’s good?” His response? “Everything or it wouldn’t be on the menu…but the garlic rolls are popular.” Garlic rolls? Sold!

Let me just tell you now: These are addicting! Terribly, terribly addicting! Warm, buttery, melt in your mouth and garlic–yummy, yummy garlic!

Lucky for us, the kid couldn’t get through half of his (did I mention they are really big?) so hubs and I split it. Sharing? Argh!

Rensselaer, Indiana Pizza Parlor

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

Since it was around lunch time (I can’t believe we made it in somewhere at a normal time!) A Slice of Pie Pizza was serving pizza by the slice. Definitely unusual for an Indiana town but a welcome surprise.

Even with all of the extras on the menu, it didn’t take us long to decide. We just wanted pizza. Well, pizza and an order of garlic rolls, as you already know.

We had a half pepperoni and a half mushroom and sausage pizza. We were so full from those garlic rolls, though, we barely made a dent in our pizza. I had to grab a box to bring the rest home!

Go There

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana

This Indiana pizza parlor has a really nice menu: Side items, fresh salads, and pasta.

So brightly decorated, you wouldn’t believe what an improvement A Slice of Pie Pizza is from the old and decrepit building it once was!

Small Towns: Destinations, not Drive-Thrus! I’m Jessica Nunemaker and THIS is little Indiana!

Find pictures in Indiana on my Flickr photostream or on the new little Indiana Tumblr blog.

Just don’t forget to tell ’em that  little Indiana sent you!

A Slice of Pie Pizza
305B N. College Avenue
Rensselaer, Indiana 47978
219.866.8682

View Larger Map

Don’t miss a moment. Subscribe to little Indiana and receive instant updates to stay on top of everything “little.”

little Indiana: Where to Stay, Play, and Eat in Small Towns in Indiana. Discovering Indiana’s best small towns! Now get little Indiana on your Kindle.

Targeted. Relevant. Affordable! little Indiana advertising.

You don't want to miss this. Sign up for free updates.

About the Author:

Jessica Nunemaker is the Owner of Little Indiana.com. More than a website, Little Indiana is a book, "Little Indiana: Small Town Destinations" (IU Press) awarded first place in the "Best in Indiana Journalism for a Nonfiction Book" by the Indiana Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists. Little Indiana is also a bi-monthly newspaper column in a local paper and a PBS segment on the former Emmy award-winning program, "The Weekly Special."

3 Comments

  1. Arlene March 31, 2010 at 6:42 pm

    There is this local pizza place that offers garlic knots and they are so good all butteyr and lots of garlic. Who doesn’t! Gosh, that reminds me there are some new pizza places nearby and I need a pizza fix.

    Welcome to The Travel Blogroll too! 😉

  2. Simply Life March 26, 2010 at 1:29 pm

    Oh that looks great!
    .-= Simply Life´s last blog ..Peanut Butter and Nutella Oatmeal Cookies! =-.

  3. Jenn AKA The Leftover Queen March 26, 2010 at 11:18 am

    Oh yes, garlic rolls. I have had those before, and you are right – super addicting! 🙂

    Welcome to The Foodie Blogroll! 🙂

Leave A Comment

This website uses cookies and third party services. Ok