Hartley Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana

Hartley Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana Vintage Postcards


Hartley’s Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana is a fun find! A really small town, Arcadia possesses just under 1700 residents (as of the 2013 census). Yet a stronger love for the community would be hard to find! But the bargains certainly aren’t. Across the board, the prices are great.

You’ll easily locate this unique two-level Indiana antique shop and furniture store downtown.

Hartley Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana

Hartley Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana

Hartley Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana


When you step inside, you can’t help but notice the antique furniture. There’s a lot of big, beautiful pieces here! Sideboards, dressers, shelving. The pieces are true antique shop variety, not junk shop or flea market quality. They are ready to head to your home!

A couple rows of brightly colored handmade quilts and blankets caught my eye. They are so well-made. I quickly spotted a wonderful assortment of antique books including some old textbooks. Shining Ball jars with neat looking clasps on the top were here as well.

At Hartley’s Antiques and Furniture, you’ll certainly find a big selection!

Arcadia, Indiana Antique Store

Hartley Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana

Hartley Antiques and Furniture in Arcadia, Indiana


One half of this Hamilton County antique shop is devoted to antiques while the other half, which is in an attached building, is a mix of furniture and, you guessed it, more antiques! The entire second floor will blow your mind. It is enormous! It looks like it was once an apartment but there’s all these cubicles as well…it’s really unusual and fun to poke through.

This is also where the gorgeous vintage headboards reside as well as many table and chair sets. You could furnish a home for a fraction of what you would pay in the big city! Even I couldn’t leave empty-handed this time.

I picked up a big bag of Legos for $20 that I’ll be holding on to until Christmas. I also snagged a handful of children’s books that I have never, ever, EVER seen before–and they are just the cutest things! I purchased (Amazon Affiliate Links): Alexander and the Magic Mouse, Mr. Tall and Mr. Small, and George and The Robbers among others. The boys just love them!

Go There

This antique shop is huge, the owner is so nice. Even  her son, who owns a local excavation company, stopped in to say “hey.” I love that small town atmosphere and I love Hartley’s Antiques and Furniture’s selection! Make a short afternoon of it (if that’s all you can spare). Take the train and you’ll have an hour or two to spend in this cute Indiana town. Though in my opinion–that’s not nearly long enough.

Small Towns: Destinations, not Drive-Thrus! I’m Jessica Nunemaker and THIS is little Indiana!

Just don’t forget to tell ’em that  little Indiana sent you!

Hartley Interiors & Antiques
103 E. Main Street
Arcadia, Indiana 46030
317.984.3424

View Larger Map

Targeted. Relevant. Affordable! little Indiana advertising.

You don't want to miss this. Sign up for free updates.