Isabella Marie's Antique and Variety Store in Greencastle, Indiana Vintage Bottles

Isabella Marie’s Antique and Variety Store in Greencastle, Indiana Vintage Bottles


Isabella Marie’s Antiques and Things in Greencastle, Indiana is a wonderful spot to do a bit of bargain shopping.

With fifteen different consignment vendors at this Putnam County antiques and more shop, there is just enough to browse through and look over without it being too overwhelming!

Isabella Marie’s Antiques and Things in Greencastle, Indiana

Isabella Marie's Antique and Variety Store in Greencastle, Indiana Vintage Cookbooks

Isabella Marie’s Antique and Variety Store in Greencastle, Indiana Vintage Cookbooks


I drove right by Isabella Marie’s Antiques and Things before quickly turning around and fixing that mistake! Boy, am I glad I did!

When we entered this sprawling Indiana antique store and consignment shop, we were told about a special sale going on. They had hidden a play rat somewhere. If you found it, you would get the discount listed on the attached tag!

I thought that that sounded like a really fun idea–and something that could keep our boys busy! So, I told them to see which one of them could find it first. I turned to take a pic of a group of toys and…I found it! That had to be some kind of a record.

Greencastle, Indiana Antiques

Isabella Marie's Antique and Variety Store in Greencastle, Indiana Exterior

Isabella Marie’s Antique and Variety Store in Greencastle, Indiana Exterior


There are a ton of gently used toys at Isabella Marie’s Antiques and Things! I mean a TON of toys! All the name brands you know and love are right here–inside and out! From vintage toys to newer, good as new items, the shelves are full of them.

Our boys found a great bucket of miscellaneous soldiers for their outdoor battles. The youngest also found a bag of cars and the oldest got a few books. Everyone was thrilled!

But they weren’t alone! I couldn’t resist a bit of vintage wall art. I love those old prints and two caught my eye. For just $4 a piece, I decided to go for it.

That’s the thing about this Central Indiana antique shop. There’s so much good stuff you just can’t help it! There are shelves of books, wall art here, there, and everywhere, household items, general decor, and a nice selection of Pyrex inside.

Go There

The people are so nice here. If you are lucky, maybe you’ll head in on a day when you, too, can try your luck at finding “Rodney the Rat!”

Pop in to Isabella Marie’s Antiques and Things in Greencastle, Indiana and see what treasures you can find!

Small Towns: Destinations, not Drive-Thrus! I’m Jessica Nunemaker and THIS is little Indiana!

Just don’t forget to tell ’em that  little Indiana sent you!

Isabella Marie’s Antiques and Things
614 S Bloomington Street
Greencastle, Indiana 46135
765.653.0370

View Larger Map

Targeted. Relevant. Affordable! little Indiana advertising.