Papa Bill’s Pizza Goes Heavy on the Cheese

Jessica Nunemaker — Tue, 05 Jan 2010 14:30:00 +0000

You know my great love and big addiction to pizza. Seriously. I can’t get enough! Hot, cold, a couple days past its prime…it doesn’t matter and I’m not ashamed to admit it!. As you can see from these images of loveliness…I found another great small town pizzeria.

Papa Bill’s Pizza opened up in little Rensselaer, Indiana – and it was good. Very, very good. Kind of funny for a town that already has three pizza places! Do they really need one more?

Yes! We got: a sausage and a pepperoni. I know: we are totally creatures of habit. I will say, however, that in the interest of research, I had to sample both, and I greatly preferred the sausage over the pepperoni (which is usually so not the case) but I think that is because the fennel seed in it really added to the overall flavor. Mmm!

We also bought a side order of cheese bread. Can you say ooey gooey? I can, of course, that’s hard to do with a mouthful of piping hot melty cheese, but there you go.

Prices were okay. It wasn’t any 80 cent cup of coffee but still better than those tasteless slabs of pie offered by the big chains. Who goes to those places, anyway?

Bottom-line: You gotta go and, when you do, make it a sausage with a side of cheese bread. YUM!
Since this writing, I have been informed that Papa Bills Pizza has closed. August 2010.
Papa Bill’s Pizza
2605 N McKinley Ave.
Rensselaer IN 47978
219.866.8177

View Larger Map

littleindiana.com » cheese bread

Papa Bill’s Pizza Goes Heavy on the Cheese