Rensselaer, Indiana: Papa Bill's Pizza

Papa Bill’s Pizza opened up in little Rensselaer, Indiana and it was good. Very, very good.

Kind of funny for a town that already has three pizza places! They must really like their pizza in Rensselaer!

Rensselaer, Indiana: Papa Bill’s Pizza

It’s your standard small Indiana town pizza joint on the inside. Very nice people.

We got a half Sausage and a half Pepperoni Pizza. I know: we are totally creatures of habit.

I will say, however, that in the interest of research, I had to sample both. I greatly preferred the sausage over the pepperoni (which is usually so not the case) but I think that is due to the Fennel Seed.  Yum!

We also bought a side order of cheese bread.  Can you say ooey gooey?  I can.

Of course, that’s hard to do with a mouthful of piping hot melty cheese, but there you go.

The Real Deal

Rensselaer, Indiana: Papa Bill's Pizza

You gotta go. Forget those tasteless slabs of big box pizza. Anything is better than that.

When you do get over there to Rensselaer, make it a Sausage Pizza with a side of Cheese Bread.That’s good stuff!

See more Papa Bill’s Pizza images and other pictures in Rensselaer, Indiana on my Flickr photostream.

Since this writing, I have been informed that Papa Bills Pizza has closed. August 2010.

Papa Bill’s Pizza
2605 N McKinley Avenue
Rensselaer, Indiana 47978
219.866.8177

View Larger Map

little Indiana: Where to Stay, Play, and Eat in Small Towns in Indiana. Discovering Indiana’s best small towns! Now get little Indiana on your Kindle.

New! Offering affordable online advertising for your small Indiana business! little Indiana Businesses is the online presence that you’ve been looking for.

Related posts:

1. A Slice of Pie Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana: Garlicky Goodness
2. Rick’s Pizza in Rensselaer, Indiana is Ridiculously Good
3. Marcella’s Pizza in Wheatfield, Indiana: Yes, Please!